Veganism: "A philosophy and way of living which seeks to exclude—as far as is possible and practicable—all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose; and by extension, promotes the development and use of animal-free alternatives for the benefit of humans, animals and the environment. Vegan antinatalists oppose human procreation, believing that overpopulation and pollution are destroying the planet Many online forums devoted to the discussion of these beliefs make it … Discussion. Eventually, the rubber hits the road. And I get it. After reviewing the figures, I concluded that veganism "is the only ethical response to what is arguably the world's most urgent social justice issue". We choose to either participate in the protection of these natural systems, or to destroy them at our own peril. Destroying a strawman of your making does not invalidate your opponent’s argument. 1. However, a vegan diet which is based on fresh fruit and vegetables, beans, pulses, cereals and grains, can be much cheaper than relying on animal products such as cheese or meat. The vegan argument that “animal farming is destroying the planet” is a falsehood. The vegan diet is widely regarded to be better for the planet than those that include animal products, but not all plant-based foodstuffs have a small environmental footprint. Best way to destroy this argument? Animal Welfare Arguments for Veganism. I hate meat eaters they are destroying this world, I love fellow vegans because we need to save this planet, also those poor animals who get slaughtered for the selfish meat eaters. Step 1: REMIND THEM THAT HUMANS HAVE BEEN EATING MEAT FOR THOUSANDS OF YEARS No vegans are aware of this, but one thing they are aware of is that if humans have been doing something for thousands of years, it must be acceptable. In the end, pescetarianism is really just a diet; it is not an ethical stance, and it is not an environmentally-friendly choice. A professor of animal science at Oregon State University, Davis based his argument on the theory that modern crop harvesting kills more animals than eating cows who grazed on pasture. Close. A vegan diet is generally very healthy, but doctors have warned about the potential lack of B12, an important vitamin for brain function that is found in meat, eggs and cows’ milk. However, it’s science that offers the biggest contribution to the “vegan for the planet” argument. 4. February 20, 2020 1,198 Shares. Let’s take a deeper look at this recurring argument and let the facts speak for themselves. Mic'ing the vegan community with scientifically sound arguments to defend themselves and fight on behalf of the animals, health justice, and the environment. Not what you're looking for? Here we list 15 ways in which Veganism helps the environment, backed up by bombshell scientific and environmental studies that will open your mind to what Veganism is really able to achieve! #2: The Vegan Diet is Better for the Environment “Cow farts are destroying the environment.” “Animal based diets will boil the oceans.” This is nonsense. That is the ludicrous conclusion of a 2003 paper by Steven Davis published in the Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics. But that is not true. Veganism Argument Without Analogies. A vegan diet results in more animal deaths than an omnivorous one. Does a vegan diet lead to more animal deaths than an omnivorous one? Discussion. https://inourishgently.com/8-big-arguments-veganism-destroyed Close. An argument, heard often, is that plant-based diets are production-intensive and increase emissions of greenhouse gases. Water conservation. First off, you know that an argument is on its last stand when it’s erratic. An animal-based agriculture is destroying the environment and all of the sentient beings therein. Your details are safe with us, and we promise we won’t share them with third parties. Deciding to become vegan is not just about the health benefits. Posted by 18 hours ago. Consequently, he finds the recent shift towards plant-based diets troubling, though he’s sympathetic to the arguments for doing so. It’s time to wake up. The second reason is that I didn’t want a whole new group of idealistic young people to destroy their health. 4. Best way to destroy this argument? im vegan come at me with your weak arguements! a farmed animal) eating anything in-between. A sustainable future must be centered on a return to more local farming. So vegetarians are on drawdown of their biological reserves. Rather, the food goes directly from the soil, to your plate, without anyone (i.e. Ethics. This may be the most common type of ethical argument made about going vegan. A study conducted by Carnegie Mellon investigated how vegetarian and ‘healthy’ diets could be harmful to the environment. And the vegan diet is going to ensure the momentum continues downhill. Affirmative Argument Animal agriculture requires massive amounts of land, food, energy, and water; results in polluted land, water, and air; and causes immense animal suffering. The argument is that factory farms are extremely cruel to animals, fur farms treat animals abusively, animal research labs treat animals cruelly, and so forth—and going vegan is the best way to protest this cruelty. It's time for vegans to take a long, hard look at their lifestyles and choose the path that is truly more ethical. That’s just science for you today folks! All the arguments above focus on the problems that arise from mass production of animal products; intensive farming, factory animals, mass slaughter. by Marla Rose. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts https://www.debatingeurope.eu/focus/arguments-for-and-against-veganism Another week and it’s time for another embarrassing misfire by prickly meat-eaters trying to pin Something Bad on vegans. Someone told me that vegans do more harm than omnis because of eating expensive imported produce instead of locally raised animals. Archived. Selectively appealing to biological determinism also ignores the fact … 1. After all, there's nothing … Going vegan cuts out the middle moo, so to speak, as there is no one being being housed on any land, requiring any food, in order to feed you. What’s more, any food in any diet that either comes from “conventional” (industrial) agriculture or has been transported thousands of miles to get to our table, that’s a model that cannot be sustainable. The idea that vegan diets are expensive seems to come from ready meals, processed foods and from restaurant menus – some of which have been known to overprice vegan options. 0. Environmental Arguments Against Veganism Whilst this potato plantation uses quite a bit of water, it is only a small fraction of what animal farming uses. Getting your nutrients from plant foods allows more room in your diet for health-promoting options like whole grains, fruit, nuts, seeds and vegetables, which are packed full of beneficial fibre, vitamins and minerals. Posted by 1 year ago. The concept of a food chain is a human construct that imposes a rigid and competitive hierarchy among species, rather than a good faith understanding of the complexity of the ecosystems to which we belong. Try… Can a vegan love a meat eater. Going vegan is a great opportunity to learn more about nutrition and cooking, and improve your diet. You know I’m sure there’s a lot of compelling back and forth, … back and forth, … back and forth arguments! A vegetarian diet — and especially a vegan diet — does not provide for the long-term maintenance and repair of the human body. Veganism, however, minimises land usage, as far fewer resources are needed to feed you as a vegan. A common objection to veganism is that if we all ate a plant-based diet, we would have to cultivate more land and that this would result in our killing more sentient nonhumans. For the environment. Everybody’s doormat. r/DebateAVegan: A place for open discussion about veganism and vegan issues, including genuine questions or arguments about animal rights and … Press J to jump to the feed. Fishing is destroying our oceans, contrary to the environmentally-friendly image many pescetarians wish to paint of their diet. As the World Burns: “Vegans Are Destroying the Planet” and Other Half-Baked Claims When meat-eaters point a finger at vegans for consuming “water-intensive” crops, three fingers point right back at them. Is it true that harvesting crops for vegans kills more animals than farming grass-fed beef? For all of these reasons, and for our general good health, we should consider reducing the amount of meat in our diet.
